Nov 20th 2012, 14:36:12
The question is: if someone puts you in DR, can you continue to grab, and under what circumstances is more grabbing OK? Most wouldn't want to say people in DR just *can't* grab, so probably if they continue to hit smaller countries as usual, it's okay. Once you skew heavy to jets and hit people who can make easy retals, that's abuse. #20 did that, and #20's DR also looked intentionally inflicted, plus it was done at a point to cover him for the remainder of the round.
OTOH I think #44 was well-defended and he took some actual damage. He had to invest in SDI and he still ate 2k damages from nukes, plus chems, from random people trying to screw with a highly ranked country. He's not in GDI anyway so he doesn't really have a reason to single tap. So did he cross a line when he hit you three times? That gave you the power to stock turns and AB him to nothing (he was still competitive and in the top ten at that point) or even to attempt a killrun, so if he was really abusing his way to the top, you had the opportunity to stop it. It's possible you could consider his play abuse, but it's much more grey than other cases.
What you're arguing for actually sounds like it's coming from the opposite direction, that you don't have a problem with what he's doing with his own country or his method of netting so much as you care what he's done to you, messing your set. That's controversial - do you think that countries in GDI shouldn't be able to get beat up heavily, farmed, multi-tapped, whatever? For argument's sake, compare it to someone not in DR who hits you five times, or heck, someone who retals a reasonable retal. So you lost over a thousand acres and if you try to recoup it'd take multiple hits and the mad dog will probably ruin your round as well. That player couldn't be deleted, obviously. So what do you propose exactly? A new sort of GDI system? And, considering it from this perspective, that players can already ruin your round completely by the book, what kind of play should be deleted the way things are right now?
Just a thought exercise to chew on for people that wanna spend time scrutinizing this stuff from multiple directions and looking at the nuance of different possible layers. :D
Originally
posted by
Mr. Titanium:
Watch your mouth boy, I have never been accused of cheating on any server nor deleted before you just did right there.