Jan 12th 2012, 17:45:57
here is the real scenario. An FA allows a fellow clan member to take a LG on its country as Reps for an FA mistake. The country fails the original LG then grabs again to actually get the land.
Later (18 hrs later) The FA decides to make a LG. Later when the retal for said LG is taken the country is not in DR.
I dont see how what happens previous to the LG has any effect on the outcome of the retal. the retaler still netted 3500 acres gain on the exchange with a single retal.
There is no "reverse" two stepping happening in actuality. NA believes that the country should be retalled 2:1 and stated that you must wait 72 hrs before making a LG. My response is that waiting 72 hrs would not have changed the amount of land the country had when making the LG and would not have an effect on the returns for the retal, so what would waiting have accomplished? Nothing in my mind; same outcome same results.
Later (18 hrs later) The FA decides to make a LG. Later when the retal for said LG is taken the country is not in DR.
I dont see how what happens previous to the LG has any effect on the outcome of the retal. the retaler still netted 3500 acres gain on the exchange with a single retal.
There is no "reverse" two stepping happening in actuality. NA believes that the country should be retalled 2:1 and stated that you must wait 72 hrs before making a LG. My response is that waiting 72 hrs would not have changed the amount of land the country had when making the LG and would not have an effect on the returns for the retal, so what would waiting have accomplished? Nothing in my mind; same outcome same results.